Ex Parte LAWSER et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2002-1136                                                        
          Application 09/030,601                                                      

          Internet Service Provider because McMullin teaches that the proxy           
          38, provides the function of converting the call to an Internet             
          Telephony format which is not at the Internet Service Provider.             
          See pages 6 and 7 of the brief and pages 1 and 2 of the reply               
          brief.                                                                      
               Upon our review of McMullin, we find that McMullin teaches             
          that the proxy IVRS would be equipped with the necessary software           
          and hardware to interconnect the caller with the sound equipment            
          of the proxy.  See McMullin, column 11, lines 38 through 40.                
          McMullin further teaches that the IVRS is part of a called party            
          proxy 38.  See McMullin, figure 2.  McMullin teaches that figure            
          2 shows a functional block diagram of the logical network                   
          elements interconnected with a called party proxy 38 which is               
          advantageously employed to provide an audio interactive voice               
          response to the calling party that attempts to call a subscriber            
          whose telephone link is busy.  See McMullin, column 8, lines 13             
          through 20.  McMullin teaches that the Data Communications                  
          Service shown as element 50 in figure 2 is an Internet Service              
          Provider.  See McMullin, column 1, lines 20 through 25, and                 
          column 5, lines 34 through 63.  Therefore, McMullin teaches that            
          the called party proxy 38 performs the function of providing the            
          necessary formatting of the incoming call and via the IVRS 14.              
                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007