Ex Parte VIMPARI - Page 4




               Appeal No. 2002-1435                                                                                                    
               Application No. 08/861,213                                                                                              

                       Section 102 rejection of claims 18-23 and 26-35                                                                 
                       Appellant traverses the rejection of claims 18-23 and 26-35 as being anticipated                                
               by Vucetic.  The rejection reads the “subscriber station information” on the dialing rule                               
               database described by the reference.  According to appellant, however, Vucetic fails to                                 
               show a data transfer procedure of the radio connection between the terminal equipment                                   
               and the data transfer system being selected on the basis of the subscriber station                                      
               information, as expressed in instant claim 18.                                                                          
                       Although appellant’s arguments suggest otherwise, appellant’s “Summary of the                                   
               Invention” in the Brief does not point out any particular difference in the radio                                       
               connection per se on the basis of the subscriber station information.  Nor do we find                                   
               any description of such in the instant disclosure.  For example, as shown in instant                                    
               Figures 3 and 4, and described at pages 7 and 8 of the specification, telephone or                                      
               telefax is selected, based on subscriber station information, by control of switches 416,                               
               417, rather than by adjusting RF part 413.                                                                              
                       Vucetic describes “dialing rules,” and provides an example of an “end of dialing                                
               sequence” that may detect the end of the dialing sequence for “911.”  Vucetic further                                   
               describes type of dialing rules that may be created, such as:                                                           
                       autodial options that enable the WT [wireless terminal] to immediately dial                                     
                       a number when an off hook condition is sensed, sending of a signal to an                                        
                       operator when an interdigit time out interval of a particular duration is                                       
                       sensed as well as other dialing rules allowing the recognition of long                                          
                       distance numbers, the interposing of telephone credit card accounts, and                                        
                       other flexible functions associated with dialing.                                                               

                                                                 -4-                                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007