Appeal No. 2002-1868
Application 09/059,033
transferring linked macro of log files's command based on user's
command in term of real time factor" (FR4).
Appellant argues that "[w]hile arguable Yuasa teaches some
type of storing of commands and conventional macro generation,
Yuasa does not teach the combination of storing commands in a log
file and transferring the commands under user control from a log
file to a macro" (Br6-7) and that the examiner admits that Yuasa
does not describe transferring commands under user control (Br7).
It is argued that Dwyer's "operator interaction" only launches
macro functions and does not move commands from a log file into a
macro file (Br7). It is argued that the examiner's reliance on
Clark for teaching a log file maintaining a real-time sequential
history of user commands is unreasonable because storing policy
data in telecommunications networks would not lead one to provide
a log file maintaining a real-time sequence of user commands for
the claimed purpose of transferring commands under user control
to the macro file (Br7). Appellant argues that the rejection
fails to provide motivation for combining the references to
render obvious the claimed invention (Br7-8).
The examiner expands on the teachings of the references
(EA18-22), but we do not consider these responses to address
appellant's arguments.
Dwyer and Clark do not support the examiner's rejection.
Dwyer discloses a system and method for acquiring and archiving
- 4 -
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007