Ex Parte IACOBOVICI et al - Page 9




          Appeal No. 2002-2237                                         Page 9           
          Application No. 09/336,046                                                    


               We agree with the examiner (answer, page 6) that a linked                
          list is in effect a simplified tree structure, and we take notice             
          of this fact2.  We further find that in the stored network                    
          displayed in figure 3, the addresses have pointers that point to              
          a previous entry.  For example, address 8 includes pointer 7,                 
          which points to address 7.  In addition, address 7 includes                   
          pointer 6, which points to address 6.  Address 6 includes pointer             
          0, which points to address 0.  Claim 1 recites "(b.1) searching a             
          content addressable memory, which contains at least a portion of              
          the second entry, for a reference to the first entry in the                   
          linked list."  It is unclear as to how the stored network of                  
          figure 3 is implemented in a content addressable memory; i.e., it             
          unclear as to whether figure 3 is a content addressable memory.               
          In addition, it is unclear as to whether figure 3 discloses                   
          searching a content addressable memory, which contains at least a             
          portion of a second entry, for a reference to a first entry in a              
          linked list.                                                                  
               From our review of the portions of Holtz relied upon by the              
          examiner (col. 6, line 34 through col. 7, line 58) we find no                 
          support for the examiner's position that the reference suggests               

               2 Pascal Plus, Data Structures, Second Edition, © 1988 D.C. Heath and    
          Company, page 393.  A copy of the pertinent page is enclosed with the         
          Decision.                                                                     







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007