Appeal No. 2003-0065
Application 09/491,284
matter," Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary (G.&C. Merriam Co.
1977). In our opinion, the definition "to make an integral part
of" must be read in the context of the other definitions to mean
enclosed or surrounded, but, in any case, the claim term
"embedded within" compels this choice of meanings. The head 17
in Brezoczky is not "embedded within" the crystal sheet 52.
While Fig. 6 shows a pole tip embedded in the slider, it is not
embedded within in the pads 64. The rejection of claims 1 and 2
is reversed.
Claims 10-12, 26, 31, and 33-39
Appellants also argue that Brezoczky fails to teach a slider
that includes a pad with a wedge-shaped portion (Br10). It is
argued that the thin sheet of single crystal material in Fig. 5
has high hardness and therefore does not constitute a pad (Br10).
It is stated (Br10) that claim 10 recites "A slider, comprising
... a pad which maintains substantially continuous contact with
the medium during the read and write operations."
We do not find where the examiner addresses these arguments.
Nevertheless, the thin sheet of single crystal 52 attached to the
slider body 56 in Fig. 5 is considered a "pad." The contacting
members 64 attached to the slider body 62 in Fig. 6 are also
considered "pads." The claim does not define the composition of
the pad so as to distinguish over the sheet 52 or members 64. We
also consider the slider 16 made of a single crystal in Fig. 2 to
- 7 -
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007