Ex Parte EIDSON et al - Page 8




          Appeal No. 2003-0556                                                        
          Application 09/185,248                                                      


          diverse formats mixed by digital mixers, the analog sources of              
          data are first digitized after they have been mixed for                     
          subsequent common mixing by the digital mixers of Alexander to              
          yield a mixed digital audio output stream.  PCM data is                     
          bidirectionally exchanged in Alexander as best represented in               
          Figure 1B which is representative of the broader showing in                 
          Figure 1A.  The focus of this reference is a CODEC (Figure 2A),             
          a feature also suggested in Bergher as well as shown in the far             
          right corner of Farhangi's Figure 2 teaching to provide an analog           
          output.  Thus, the additional reliance upon Hinderks is                     
          cumulative for the teachings of a CODEC.  Note also the teachings           
          in Figure 2A of Alexander and the use of a well-known AC'97                 
          digital controller and related circuitry which is what appellants           
          have disclosed as well to be known in the art.  See specification           
          page 1.  Alexander's digital mixer system 300 is shown in various           
          embodiments in Figures 3A-3C.                                               
               We have also indicated earlier that it appears that the                
          input processor discussion at the first column of 571 of Bergher            
          would have indicated to the artisan that the inputted, coded data           
          would have been decoded to give a common or consistent PCM data             
          stream (Figure 2) for processing by the DSP core structure shown            


                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007