Ex Parte Rudow et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2003-0628                                                        
          Application No. 09/860,493                                 Page 4           


          which computer is located on the golf cart.  See, e.g., drawing             
          figures 1 and 2, column 3, lines 64 through column 4, line 21 and           
          claim 1 of Bonito.                                                          
               While Bonito indicates that the computer and display monitor           
          associated therewith may be installed on the dashboard of the               
          golf cart as illustrated in figure 1, one of ordinary skill in              
          the art would have recognized that Bonito does not require any              
          particular installation location for the mobile computer so long            
          as the mobile computer is located on the golf cart.  See, e.g.,             
          claim 1, item b of Bonito wherein the computer is recited as                
          being coupled to a golf cart without specifying a particular                
          location for the coupling.                                                  
               As correctly found by the examiner, Dillon (the other                  
          applied reference) discloses that mounting electronic equipment             
          in vehicles, such a police vehicles, on the underside of the roof           
          or ceiling of the vehicle results in several advantages including           
          the avoidance of a knee hazard associated with the prior art                
          mounting of such electronic equipment near the vehicle dashboard.           
          Given the additional disclosure of Dillon, we agree with the                
          examiner that one of ordinary skill in the art would have been              
          reasonably led to mount the computer equipment, including the               
          display monitor of Bonito on the underside of the golf cart roof            







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007