Ex Parte KOCHERLAKOTA et al - Page 3




          Appeal No. 2003-1113                                                        
          Application No. 09/286,124                                                  

          objects on another side of the network (col. 2, lines 40-67).               
          Noble does not disclose sending the messages as a batch.                    
               Itoh discloses an object-oriented operating system wherein             
          an object accesses another object by calling into its meta-space,           
          a meta-space being a set of meta-objects that manages a simple              
          object (page 4).  “The meta-objects are associated with the                 
          simple object via a descriptor object that holds a reference to             
          all the required meta-objects.”  See id.  A meta-space can be               
          represented by an object called a reflector which gathers                   
          statistics on message communication patterns, thereby enabling              
          the meta-space to reconfigure itself to change the send mode from           
          a simple send per invocation to a batched send (pages 4 and 10-             
          11).  Batching two or more messages into a single packet reduces            
          execution time (page 10).                                                   
               The examiner argues:                                                   
                    [I]t would have been obvious to one having                        
               ordinary skill in the art at the time the invention was                
               made to incorporate the message batching technique                     
               applied on the distributed object network as taught by                 
               Itoh into the Noble’s system.  Doing so would speed up                 
               the performance on the distributing object network.                    
               [answer, page 4]                                                       
                                        * * *                                         
                    Examiner notes Itoh discloses a network using                     
               object oriented technology, including message batching                 
               technique [Itoh page 10]. [answer, page 8]                             
                                        * * *                                         
                    Examiner notes both Noble and Itoh teach Object                   
               Oriented technology applied to a network environment                   

                                          3                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007