Ex Parte JOCHEM - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2003-1529                                                        
          Application No. 08/499,442                                                  

          terms of the composition of the adsorption zone and the feedstock,          
          the adsorption zone of Bauer has an active alumina zone and a               
          molecular sieve zone which are operated the same as the claimed             
          adsorption zone, and estimates a ratio Q for Bauer of about 0.20            
          based on the entire column (id.).  Therefore the examiner concludes         
          that the Bauer process inherently has a mass transfer zone and              
          equilibrium zone within the limits as claimed by appellants (id.;           
          see also the Answer, page 6).                                               
               Bauer discloses the drying of cracked gases such as a cracked          
          propane stream containing ethylene (col. 1, ll. 56-60).  Appellant          
          discloses that the feedstock may be gases originating from steam            
          cracking or fluid catalytic cracking, or natural gases such as              
          methane or ethane “type” (specification, page 2, l. 25- page 3,             
          l. 3).  Bauer teaches using a “minor bed” by replacing “two-three           
          feet of the usual molecular sieve desiccant with, say, activated            
          alumina,” thus protecting the expensive molecular sieve (col. 1,            
          ll. 45-49; col. 2, ll. 15-19; col. 3, l. 66-col. 4, l. 3), with the         
          alumina protecting the sieve material from fouling by polymers as           
          well as effectively removing water (col. 2, ll. 25-30; col. 4, ll.          
          4-9).                                                                       



                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007