Appeal No. 2003-1858 Application No. 09/073,871 are absent in the reference. Shipp relates to a system for generating electronic and printed reports of medical treatments and procedures wherein captured images are combined with dictated text into integrated medical records (col. 1, lines 5-10). Shipp discloses that during or after the surgical procedure, the surgeon dictates pertinent information describing the medical procedure related to the video image observed on a monitor from which still images are selected for storage (col. 3, lines 12- 17). Additionally, Shipp discloses that the voice recognition includes features for recognizing certain words as commands for operating the system such as one for frame grab command which captures a frame from the video string and delivers to the storage device (col. 3, lines 46-59). Therefore, the still images are merely captured and stored as the surgeon commands without being detected for the change over from one still image to another. As discussed above, what the Examiner characterizes in Shipp as detecting the change over from one still image to another when a voice command is received (answer, page 11), is actually a voice recognition feature of the system that helps the surgeon to operate the system by speaking the commands. In fact, the surgeon decides which frame from the video image should be stored 6Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007