Ex Parte JOHNSON et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2003-2010                                                         
          Application 09/150,549                                                       

                                       OPINION                                         
               The claims are grouped to stand or fall together (Br4).                 
          Claim 1 is taken as representative.                                          
               The examiner finds that Buxton discloses a "a data                      
          processing system having a keyboard, a plurality of objects and a            
          pointing device having at least one button and an associated                 
          movable cursor displayed within said data processing system," for            
          example, in Fig. 1 (R2).  The examiner finds that the limitation,            
          "specifying a predefined process within said data processing                 
          system said predefined process comprising a plurality of                     
          keystrokes, said plurality of keystrokes specifying a user                   
          defined executable process which may be applied to one or more               
          objects within said data processing system," reads on the macro              
          creation described at column 23, lines 50-61 (R2; EA3).  The                 
          examiner finds that the limitation, "associating said predefined             
          process with said movable cursor within said data processing                 
          system in response to a first user input," reads on placing the              
          cursor in a tool mode described at column 26, lines 1-22 (FR2).              
          The examiner finds that the limitation, "executing said                      
          predefined process on any suitable object within said data                   
          processing system in response to each subsequent graphic                     
          selection of a suitable object and depression of said at least               
          one button by a user utilizing said movable cursor" reads on                 
          depression of a button by a user using the cursor, referring to              

                                        - 4 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007