Ex Parte Hirshberg - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2004-0061                                                        
          Application 09/745,762                                                      


          large interior compartment of the bag (2) therein and divided               
          therefrom by an interior dividing wall, with the second interior            
          compartment sharing a portion of the interior surface of the                
          first large interior compartment and having a second opening in             
          the exterior surface of the bag leading only to said second                 
          interior compartment, whereby the mat may be rolled into said               
          second interior compartment and retained therein and segregated             
          from the remainder of the first large interior compartment.                 


          Shreim describes the flap (14) therein as being “attached to                
          the lower edge of the side 16 of the bag” (page 1, lines 75-84)             
          and the sheets (20, 22), in a storage position, as laying against           
          “the side of the bag” (page 1, lines 30-32).  Thus, it is clear             
          to us that the compartment defined between the side (16) of the             
          bag in Shreim and the flap (14) attached thereto for storing the            
          sheets (20, 22) would have been viewed by one of ordinary skill             
          in the art as being an exterior compartment added on to an                  
          exterior surface of the bag, and clearly distinguishable from               
          appellant’s “second interior compartment” carved out of and                 





                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007