Ex Parte Giardino et al - Page 3




              Appeal No. 2004-0495                                                             Paper 22                      
              Application No. 09/503,599                                                       Page 3                        
              transesterification catalyst, including organic and inorganic compounds of titanium,                           
              lanthanum, zinc and cobalt, is mixed with 1,3-propanediol prior to mixing with the                             
              terephthalic acid ester (3:9-28).  Still further according to the specification, the                           
              preheated 1,3-propanediol/terephthalic acid ester mixture may be injected into the ester                       
              exchange vessel at or below about the midpoint of the vessel (4:34 - 5:1).  For example,                       
                      a mixture of preheated, catalyzed 1,3-propanediol and preheated                                        
                      dimethylterephthalate is injected into the base of the exchanger, and                                  
                      additional virgin 1,3-propanediol, typically at ambient temperature, is                                
                      injected at the quarterpoint of the exchange column.  In this embodiment,                              
                      the mixture that is injected into the base of the exchanger has a lower                                
                      mole ratio of 1,3-propanediol to dimethylterephthalate and a higher                                    
                      catalyst concentration ..., such that the overall mole ratio and catalyst                              
                      concentration remain within the above-described ranges, after taking into                              
                      account the additional 1,3-propanediol that is injected at the quarter point.                          
                      In still another alternative, preheated dimethylterephthalate and preheated                            
                      catalyzed 1,3-propanediol are injected into the exchanger separately                                   
                      without premixing.  For example, the dimethylterephthalate is injected into                            
                      the base of the exchanger, and the catalyzed 1,3-propanediol is injected                               
                      at the quarterpoint.  [Specification, 5:18-31.]                                                        
              Gaseous reaction products typically include methanol vapor, acrolein and allyl alcohol,                        
              while liquid reaction products include bis(3-hydroxypropyl) terephthalate monomer, low                         
              molecular weight oligomers of 1,3-propanediol and terephthalic acid, and less than 9                           
              wt.% unreacted terephthalic acid ester (id., 6:4-23).                                                          
                      We make reference to appellants' Appeal Brief ("Brief," Paper 19, filed 11 March                       
              2003) and the Examiner's Answer ("Answer," Paper 20, mailed 3 April 2003).                                     
                      The examiner relies on the following references in his rejection.                                      
                      Armstrong et al. (Armstrong)                3,534,082             13 October 1970                      
                      Kurian et al. (Kurian)                      5,840,957             24 November 1998                     








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007