Appeal No. 2004-0621 Application No. 09/193,193 includes a conductive layer, and the insulator is separated from this conductive layer by a gap (Brief, page 3). Appellants state that this gap is formed by removal of a portion of a barrier layer disposed between the conductive layer and the insulator, while the conductive line is physically detached from the insulator and thus is capable of being removed by lifting off the conductive layer (id.). Representative independent claim 8 is reproduced below: 8. A semiconductor device that is at least partially deprocessed, the semiconductor device comprising: at least one conductive line including a conductive layer; and an insulator surrounding a portion of the conductive line, the insulator being separated from the conductive layer by a gap, the gap being formed by removal of a portion of a barrier layer disposed between the conductive layer and the insulator, the portion of the barrier layer being removed by exposing a second portion of the barrier layer by removing a portion of the insulator; and etching the portion barrier layer after the portion of the insulator is removed; and wherein the conductive line is physically detached from the insulator and is capable of being removed by lifting off the conductive layer. The examiner relies on Grill et al. (Grill), U.S. Patent No. 5,869,880, issued on Feb. 9, 1999 (filed Mar. 13, 1996), as the sole evidentiary basis for the rejections on appeal (Answer, page 3). Claims 8 and 10-15 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 102(e) as anticipated by Grill (Answer, page 4). Claim 9 stands rejected 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007