Ex Parte Platner et al - Page 4




              Appeal No. 2004-0875                                                               Page 4                
              Application No. 09/728,975                                                                               


              USPQ 795, 802 (CCPA 1981); Ex parte Davis, 80 USPQ 448, 450 (Bd. App.                                    
              1948)("comprising" leaves "the claim open for the inclusion of unspecified ingredients                   
              even in major amounts").  Thus, claim 1 does not exclude additional, unrecited                           
              elements, such as another pair of side members 55 extending in a cantilevered                            
              arrangement from the other side of the center space frame in Na’s bus frame.  As                         
              pointed out by the examiner, each pair of side members 55 extends from only one side                     
              of the center space frame.  Accordingly, either pair of side members 55, such as the                     
              pair on the right side of Figure 1 alluded to by the examiner (answer, page 3), fully                    
              responds structurally to the pair of longitudinal mainframe members recited in                           
              appellants’ claim 1.  In pointing to the right side of Figure 1, the examiner is not simply              
              ignoring the left side of Figure 1 or picking and choosing portions of the reference to                  
              reach a conclusion of anticipation, as suggested by appellants in their reply brief.                     
              Rather, the examiner (answer, page 4) correctly points out that the presence of                          
              additional structure extending from the left side of Na’s center space frame does not                    
              distinguish claim 1 from Na’s bus frame, given the open-ended language of claim 1.                       
















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007