Appeal No. 2004-1037 Application No. 09/680,387 THE INVENTION The Appellant’s claimed invention relates to a heat exchanger having a tube bundle inside of a shell. The tubes have mini-vortex generators comprising ridge members that encircle at least a portion of the exterior surface of tube. According to Appellant, “[t]he mini-vortex generators function to abruptly interrupt the flow of the shell fluid proximal to the exterior surface of the tube.” (Brief, p. 2). Claim 11 which is representative of the invention is reproduced below: 11. A heat exchanger comprising: (a) a shell; (b) a tube bundle inside the shell, the tube bundle comprising a plurality of substantially parallel tubes for passage of a first fluid, each tube having a base diameter of between about 0.5" and about 1", at least a portion of the tubes having on their exterior surface mini-vortex generators comprising two or more ridge members that encircle at least a portion of the exterior surface of a tube, the height of each ridge member being between about 0.2 mm and about 1.0 mm, the spacing between any two ridge members being between about 2 mm and about 40 mm; (c) a sinuous baffle for supporting the tubes, the sinuous baffle comprising a plurality of wiggle bar tube support members disposed between the tubes; (d) a tube inlet for passage of the first fluid into the tubes and a tube outlet for passage of the first fluid out of the tube; - 2 -Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007