Ex Parte Vozick et al - Page 4




         Appeal No. 2004-1097                                                       
         Application No. 09/924,831                                                 


         retrieving an image for display.1  Dewaele clearly discloses               
         (column 3, lines 54-67, and column 7, lines 46-49) an                      
         identification station which includes a speech recognition                 
         subassembly for providing input data via speech.  Dewaele further          
         teaches (column 9, lines 16-29) that a medical image is taken and          
         stored on a cassette which is then transferred to the                      
         identification station.  At the identification station, the                
         operator utters identification information, i.e., the operator's           
         name, the patient's name, the type of examination represented by           
         the image, the layout parameters as to how the image will be               
         processed and displayed (such as the patient's position, the               
         cassette's position, and the exposure class), and the place where          
         the image is to be printed or viewed (see column 9, line 39-               
         column 11, line 38).  Once the information is converted by the             
         speech recognition unit and stored with the image on the                   
         cassette, the cassette is removed from the identification station          
         and entered into a read out apparatus where the image is                   
         processed according to the stored processing parameters (see               
         column 11, lines 39-45).  Nowhere does the operator use a voice            
         command "to select one of the plurality of dental images for               


              1  We note that we find nothing in the claim that requires manipulation
         of the image by voice commands.                                            
                                         4                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007