Ex Parte KRAFT IV - Page 3



          Appeal No. 2004-1136                                                        
          Application No. 09/363,948                                                  

          will reverse the anticipation rejection of claims 1, 2, and 4               
          through 21.                                                                 
               Appellant argues (Brief, page 5) that Kathrow does not teach           
          or suggest a fingerprint catalog as recited in each of                      
          independent claims 1, 12, and 17.  Instead, Kathrow "describes              
          fingerprint and values storage (230) that contain one or more               
          fingerprints of a particular configuration file" (Brief, page 5).           
          Appellant explains (Brief, page 6) that Kathrow deals with one or           
          more fingerprints of a single configuration file, whereas the               
          claims recite a configuration catalogue for storing fingerprints            
          for multiple different files, each of which corresponds to an               
          executable program.  We agree.                                              
               Each of the independent claims recites a configuration file            
          catalogue containing a signature or fingerprint for each of a               
          plurality of configuration files.  Kathrow, however, discloses              
          (abstract) identifying the existence of differences between two             
          files on a personal computer, such as two versions of a Windows             
          registry file.  Kathrow explains (column 1, lines 55-57) that a             
          Windows registry file can be modified such that it could be the             
          source of improper operation of the operating system.  The                  
          improper operation can be resolved by restoring values of the               
          Windows registry that existed when the operating system                     
                                          3                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007