Appeal No. 2004-1244 Application 10/085,280 II. The merits Beusch, the examiner’s primary reference, discloses an ice making apparatus for producing granular ice. As shown in Figure 1, the apparatus includes an extruder screw 1, a cooling jacket inner wall member 6, a cooling jacket outer housing wall 7, a space 13 between the member 6 and the wall 7 for receiving a cooling medium, a cooling medium inlet port 8, a cooling medium outlet port 9, and an annular extrusion plate 20 containing a plurality of conical apertures 22. In use, water is fed into the bottom of the cooling jacket, advanced upwardly by the extruder screw, formed into ice/slush on the cold inner surface of the cooling jacket, scraped off the inner surface by the screw and advanced toward and through the conical apertures in the extrusion plate. The Beusch ice making apparatus meets all of the limitations in representative claims 1 and 4 except for those requiring (1) the evaporator body to have a continuous generally spiral groove on its outer cylindrical surface terminating in a radial outward edge (claim 1), (2) the evaporator jacket to be in interference fit against the outward edge of the spiral groove sealingly engaging the evaporator jacket against the evaporator body whereby refrigerant entering into the groove is sealingly trapped 4Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007