Ex Parte ZOMPA et al - Page 7



                    Appeal No. 2004-1421                                                                                                                                  
                    Application No. 09/471,674                                                                                                                            

                    defined in appellants' claims 5 and 10 on appeal.  We have also                                                                                       
                    reviewed the patents to Robertson and Vance relied upon by the                                                                                        
                    examiner, however, we find nothing therein which makes up for or                                                                                      
                    otherwise supplies (i.e., renders obvious) that which is lacking                                                                                      
                    in Flake.                                                                                                                                             

                    We additionally note that claims 1 and 5 on appeal require a                                                                                          
                    method and system wherein a computer associated with a given                                                                                          
                    travel service provider is configured to determine whether a                                                                                          
                    given organization member was identified in a previously received                                                                                     
                    travel notification message and to make a selection between a                                                                                         
                    first travel preparation message comprising a complete list of                                                                                        
                    travel services available to the member and a second travel                                                                                           
                    preparation message comprising only a list of updating travel                                                                                         
                    services available dependent upon whether the given member was or                                                                                     
                    was not identified in a previously received travel notification                                                                                       
                    message, and send a complete list if no prior identification is                                                                                       
                    found and only an updating list of services if the member was                                                                                         
                    identified in a previously received travel notification message.                                                                                      
                    As indicated on page 3 of appellants' specification, this                                                                                             
                    selection of which list of services a given service provider will                                                                                     
                    send to a given member minimizes redundancies.  No such system                                                                                        
                                                                                    77                                                                                    




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007