Ex Parte CHERKASOVA - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2004-1560                                                        
          Application 09/318,722                                                      


          request (column 4, lines 26 through 32; column 4, lines 18                  
          through 21).  In an alternative embodiment (Figure 15), the                 
          server cluster 103 includes a domain name server (DNS) 167.                 
          The DNS 167 is used to map or route requests from the client                
          requestors 110 through 153 to a specific server in the server               
          cluster 103.  Yu is silent as to any customers hosted on the                
          server cluster 103.  In the absence of such customers in Yu, we             
          agree with the appellant’s argument (brief, page 7) that Yu fails           
          to teach “the grouping of customers into groups in which each               
          customer is identified by a domain name,” and the “measurement of           
          the computational resources required to service said requests to            
          each of said customers.”   In summary, the anticipation rejection           
          of claims 1 and 2 is reversed.                                              
               The obviousness rejection of claims 6 and 9 is reversed                
          because the teachings of Martin do not cure the noted shortcoming           
          in the teachings of Yu.                                                     







                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007