Ex Parte STAUB et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2004-1668                                                         
          Application No. 09/466,529                                                   

          keys to form an association for each of the plurality of keys,               
          and storing, in a location of an associative database pointed to             
          by the association, a subset of a plurality of tallies associated            
          with the plurality of targets.  Claim 23 requires 1) a hashing               
          calculator, connected to a parser of fault messages for an event             
          code, target and tally, that determines a key based on the event             
          code and determines an association for the key, and 2) an                    
          associative database that is connected to the parser and stores              
          the tally in a location pointed to by the association.  Claim 24             
          requires forming a key for each unique combination of an event               
          code, target type and target, calculating a hash for the key to              
          form an association, and storing a tally connected with the key              
          in a location of an associative database.                                    
               The examiner’s arguments that the references are in similar             
          environments and that combining their teachings would optimize               
          network functions to maximize data management do not provide an              
          explanation as to how the references themselves would have led               
          one of ordinary skill in the art to combine their teachings in               
          such a manner that a system or method having the association or              
          associative database features set forth above as required by the             
          appellants’ independent claims is produced.                                  

                                           6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007