Ex Parte BOLAND - Page 3



         Appeal No. 2004-2175                                                       
         Application 09/086,627                                                     

              Rather than repeat the positions of the appellant and the             
         examiner, reference is made to the brief and reply brief for               
         appellant's positions, and to the answer for the examiner's                
         positions.                                                                 

                                      OPINION                                       
              As embellished upon here, we sustain the rejection of claims          
         1-5, 7, 9-13 and 15 for the reasons set forth by the examiner in           
         the answer, but reverse the rejection with respect to claims 14            
         and 16, essentially for the reasons argued by appellant in the             
         brief and reply brief.                                                     
              In considering appellant's arguments in the brief and reply           
         brief, they focus initially upon the subject matter of                     
         independent claim 1 on appeal based upon the feature recited               
         therein that the minimum resource allocation for the first or              
         high priority process must be guaranteed as urged initially at             
         the bottom of page 7 of the principal brief on appeal and                  
         summarized in the paragraph bridging pages 11 and 12 of the                
         principal brief on appeal.  As to this feature, we disagree with           
         appellant's urgings between pages 7 and 12 of the principal brief          
         on appeal that the principal reference to Culbert does not teach           
         or suggest this feature.                                                   
                                         3                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007