Ex Parte CHADDHA - Page 7



         Appeal No. 2004-2185                                                       
         Application 08/855,245                                                     

              either for a point-to-point situation or a multicast                  
              situation.                                                            
              These teachings appear to us to indicate to the artisan that          
         the user is able to feed (back) to the server information as to            
         the nature and extent of the scaled data stream the user wants to          
         receive.  Implicit within these teachings is the ability of the            
         users to, at any time, select the scaled data stream requirements          
         they are willing to pay for.  This can be done in real-time.               
         Thus, the entire data stream is selectable by user on a real-time          
         basis such as to either prune/eliminate or grow/add, in the                
         context of the disclosed and claimed invention.  In the dependent          
         claims noted earlier, the nature and extent of the totality of             
         the scaled data stream is not only received by the encoders but            
         is also sent by the server to the particular clients.  Because             
         Chaddha clearly teaches of the particular base layer and at least          
         two enhancement layers, this implicitly means that the user is             
         able to select and feedback the choice to the server which of the          
         base layers, first and second enhancement layers, if any, the              
         user desires to select or pay for.                                         
              This concept of user feedback to a server is more explicit            
         in the discussion in the paragraph bridging columns 12 and 13              
         which we reproduce here:                                                   

                                         7                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007