Appeal No. 2004-2295 Application No. 09/628,396 Claim 10 sets forth a moveable closure assembly comprising, inter alia, a moveable closure member, an emitter, a receiver, and a controller, with the controller operable to construct a map signature of a signal received by the receiver, and with the map signature having a first graphical shape representative of known obstructions normally within a defined field such that insertion of an unknown object within the defined field produces a variation from the first graphical shape. Claim 14 addresses a method of detecting an object in a moveable closure path comprising the steps of; transmitting a signal within a defined field, said defined field adjacent a closure path of a moveable closure member; receiving said signal as transmitted within said defined field; mapping said signal received in said step (2) as a first graphical shape representative of known obstructions normally within said defined field; and identifying a variation in said graphical shape of said step (3). The examiner concluded that the content of each of independent claims 1, 10, and 14 is anticipated by the Zhang reference (Paper No. 11). In our remand (Paper No. 21), the 4Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007