Ex Parte BROWN et al - Page 3



            Appeal No. 2004-2377                                                                          
            Application No. 09/201,353                                                                    

            positions of the appellants and the examiner regarding the merits                             
            of these rejections.                                                                          
                                              DISCUSSION                                                  
                  Both Moore and Edgar discloses laminated exterior building                              
            wall structures.                                                                              
                  The Moore structure is a roof 10 comprising a deck 11 of                                
            steel, cement, asbestos board, wood, glass reinforced plastics or                             
            the like, an adhesive layer 16 covering the upper face 12 of the                              
            deck, a foam insulating member 19 adhered to the upper face 18 of                             
            the adhesive layer, and a water barrier layer 22 affixed to the                               
            upper face 21 of the foam member.  The adhesive “is a single                                  
            layer of asphalt or mastic, or alternately is a vapor barrier                                 
            membrane built up of alternating layers of asphalt or bitumen and                             
            paper” (column 2, lines 36 through 39).                                                       
                  The Edgar structure is an exterior insulation and finish                                
            system 14 comprising a sheathing 18, an airtight barrier 20                                   
            mounted over the sheathing, an adhesive 27 applied to the                                     
            airtight barrier, a layer of insulation 28 bonded to the airtight                             
            barrier by the adhesive, and a moisture-resistant lamina                                      
            consisting of a base coat 29, a fiberglass reinforcing mesh 30                                
            and a finish coat 31 covering the exposed surface of the                                      
            insulation layer.  Edgar teaches (see column 4, lines 2 through 4                             

                                                    3                                                     



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007