Ex Parte SHIRK et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2005-0067                                                        
          Application No. 08/853,842                                                  

               DE ’283 describes a catalytic exhaust gas purification                 
          device comprising a porous, honeycomb-shaped monolithic ceramic             
          body (3) with a catalytically effective surface coating,                    
          arranged in a metallic exterior housing (1) with front-sided,               
          conical exhaust gas inlet and outlet pipes (2), wherein a                   
          thermally insulating resilient mat (preferably an expansion mat)            
          (4) is placed between the exterior housing wall and the ceramic             
          body (3) and a thermally insulating mat (5) is placed on the                
          interior side of the exhaust gas inlet and outlet cones (2) and             
          is covered by a high temperature resistant shielding plate (6).             
          (Pages 1 and 9.)                                                            
               Similarly, DE ’070 discloses a device for the catalytic                
          purification of automobile engine exhaust gases including a                 
          housing (2), at least one monolith (4), spacer mat (16), a                  
          conical transitional section (8), and an insulating mat (20)                
          disposed between the inner surface of the transitional section              
          (8) and an interior shell (12).  (Pages 11-13 and Figure 1.)                
               Regarding the rejection of appealed claims 8, 9, 24, 25,               
          27, and 28, the examiner admits that neither DE ’283 nor DE ’070            
          discloses the “provision of...slits on the sheet material of the            
          end cone.”  (Answer at 4.)  Nevertheless, the examiner held (id.            
          at 5):                                                                      

                                          5                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007