Ex Parte SMITH - Page 6



          Appeal No.2004-1526                                                         
          Application No. 09/354,052                                                  

          discloses the initiation of such a search.  For example, at                 
          column 7, lines 10 et seq., of Vora, the reference discloses                
          first and second search requests by a user.                                 
               The second step requires searching at least one local                  
          database of content information and at least one remote database            
          of content information based upon the search criteria.  Vora                
          clearly teaches, at column 6, line 60, through column 7, line 10,           
          that a server 9 searches on a local memory (e.g., mass memory 17            
          in Figure 1), and also receives searches from Internet server 63            
          (which receives search requests from server 9).  Thus, there is             
          searching, based upon the search criteria laid out by the user,             
          on at least one local database and on at least one remote                   
          (Internet server 63) database.                                              
               The only remaining question is whether Vora discloses that             
          the “content information” being searched “corresponds to                    
          information from a plurality of content sources of multiple                 
          types,” as required by instant claim 1.                                     
               We agree with the examiner that the claimed terms, “sources”           
          and “types” are so broad as to lend themselves to an accordingly            
          broad interpretation.  That is, in Vora, the server 9 and the               
          Internet server 63 are clearly different “content sources” of               
          information and they constitute “multiple types” of content                 
                                         -6-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007