Ex Parte Griffith - Page 5


                    Appeal No.  2004-1968                                                                       Page 5                      
                    Application No.  10/000,311                                                                                             
                    has indicated that claims drawn to a process of producing corn seed wherein the                                         
                    process comprises crossing a first parent corn plant with a second parent corn                                          
                    plant are allowable.  See e.g., claim 11, and Final Rejection, mailed July 1, 2003,                                     
                    wherein the examiner states claim 11 is allowed.                                                                        
                            A third aspect of the present invention is a corn plant from the inbred corn                                    
                    line LH321 further comprising “a cytoplasmic factor that is capable of conferring                                       
                    male sterility” (specification, paragraph 24); or transformed so that its genetic                                       
                    material contains one or more transgenes operably linked to one or more                                                 
                    regulatory elements” (see e.g., claims 26-28).   As appellant explains                                                  
                    (specification, paragraph 13), “[I]t should be understood that the inbred can,                                          
                    through routine manipulation of cytoplasmic or other factors, be produced in a                                          
                    male-sterile form.”  According to appellant (specification, paragraph 67)                                               
                            scientists in the filed of plant biology developed a strong interest in                                         
                            engineering the genome of plants to confer and express foreign                                                  
                            genes, or additional , or modified versions of native, or                                                       
                            endogenous, genes (perhaps driven by different promoters) in                                                    
                            order to alter the traits of a plant in a specific manner.  Such foreign                                        
                            additional and/or modified genes are referred to herein collectively                                            
                            as “transgenes”.  Over the last fifteen to twenty years several                                                 
                            methods for producing transgenic plants have been developed, and                                                
                            the present invention, in particular embodiments, also relates to                                               
                            transformed versions of the claimed inbred line.                                                                
                            A final aspect of the present invention is directed to a process of                                             
                    producing an inbred corn plant derived from a plant of the inbred corn line LH321                                       
                    (see e.g., claims 11, 19 and 30), as well as hybrid plants and seed resulting from                                      
                    such a process (see e.g., claims 12-16).  As discussed, supra, the examiner has                                         
                    indicated that claim 11 was allowable.  According to appellant’s specification                                          
                    (paragraph 56),                                                                                                         







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007