Ex Parte Tajima - Page 7



             Appeal No. 2004-2124                                                                              
             Application No.  09/795,197                                                                       

                   section 70, a shutter 101 provided above the stimulable phosphor sheet in                   
                   the image recording section and movable to a position for shielding a part                  
                   of the stimulable phosphor sheet from radiation during sectored image                       
                   recording, a shutter operating means 80, 81, 102, and 103 for controlling                   
                   the movement of said shutter, and a sectored image recording operation                      
                   control means 90 for, upon receipt of a sectored image recording                            
                   command, moving the shutter to the shielding position and controlling said                  
                   circulation and conveyance means so as to convey the stimulable                             
                   phosphor sheet in said image recording section by sectors.                                  
                   We concur, and further find that Nakajima teaches that controller 90 may be                 
             mounted separate from the housing, as shown in figure 2.  We find that figure 2 of                
             Nakajima suggests that at least two cables enter the housing (item 1) of the radiation            
             image recording and readout apparatus, one cable from the controller (item 90) and                
             another from the radiation source (item 42).  However, we find that Nakajima is silent as         
             to how the cables traverse the housing to connect with the equipment therein.  We find that       
             the skilled artisan would look to methods used for connecting cables to enclosures                
             for electrical equipment.                                                                         
                   Michaelis teaches an enclosure for electrical equipment where there are a                   
             plurality of ports (knockouts, items 31) through which cable enters the enclosure to              
             connect with equipment therein.  (See Michaelis, column 2, lines 55 –59 and figure 4).            
             These ports incorporate clamps to provide strain relief to prevent disconnection.  (See           
             Michaelis, column 4, lines 9-12 and column 2 lines 39-40).  While we recognize that               
             Michaelis is directed to cables associated with power distribution and does specify use           
             on a housing for a radiation image recording device, we find that the nature of problem           
             to be solved, connection of an electrical cable, provides the motivation to combine               
             teachings.  The motivation, suggestion or teaching may come explicitly from statements            


                                                        7                                                      



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007