Ex Parte Borcherding - Page 2



          Appeal No. 2005-0687                                                        
          Application No. 10/097,510                                                  

          rotation of the thrust collar with the shaft, the center bore               
          having a center axis that defines mutually perpendicular axial              
          and radial directions relative to the thrust collar, and the                
          thrust collar having an annular flange that projects outwardly              
          from the thrust collar exterior surface to a peripheral edge of             
          the annular flange, the annular flange having opposite interior             
          and exterior surfaces and the interior surface extending both               
          axially and radially over the thrust collar exterior surface,               
          and,                                                                        
               the annular flange having a peripheral surface at the flange           
          peripheral edge, the peripheral surface extending axially between           
          the flange interior surface and the flange exterior surface and             
          the flange peripheral surface being parallel to the thrust collar           
          center axis.                                                                
               In addition to the admitted prior art found in appellant's             
          specification, the examiner relies upon the following references            
          as evidence of obviousness:                                                 
          Fruhstorfer                  1,945,219              Jan. 30, 1934           
          Lakin                        4,711,590              Dec.  8, 1987           
          Williams et al.              5,575,355              Nov. 19, 1996           
          (Williams)                                                                  
               Appellant's claimed invention is directed to a lubricant               
          retention assembly of an electric motor that has a self-contained           
          lubricant reservoir.  The assembly comprises                                
               [A] thrust collar mounted on the motor shaft and a bearing             
               cap surrounding the thrust collar, where the thrust collar             
               has an annular flange that throws lubricant leaking along              
               the shaft radially outwardly toward the bearing cap and the            
               bearing cap has an angled interior surface that deflects the           
               lubricant thrown by the annular flange into the motor                  
               interior and toward the lubricant reservoir [page 1 of                 
               specification].                                                        

                                         -2-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007