Ex Parte Hull et al - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2005-0742                                                              
          Application No. 10/274,579                                                        

          displaying a representation of evaluation status for each of a                    
          plurality of computation rules as well as a corresponding display                 
          and operation of at least one combining policy.                                   
                Moreover, we generally agree with appellants’ observations                  
          at pages 8 and 9 of the principal brief on appeal as applicable                   
          to claim 4, which remarks more clearly state the issue with                       
          respect to this claim on appeal.  Because appellants’ remarks                     
          here relate to the actual text at column 37 of Shasha relating to                 
          the various subfigures forming figure 20, those features relied                   
          upon by the examiner do not appear to be displayed anyway.  The                   
          statement relied upon by the examiner at the top of column 8                      
          (lines 5-9) does not appear to actually teach what the examiner                   
          asserts.  This portion of Shasha merely indicates that each                       
          conditional transition network represents a data or information                   
          pattern, whereas it is the additional teaching that any portion                   
          of the data or information pattern may be displayed on a visual                   
          display screen by the display mapping process shown in figure 2.                  
          The (internal) states of the conditional transition network                       
          10 itself do not appear to be displayed.                                          




                                             7                                              




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007