Ex Parte Roskin - Page 6




                Appeal No. 2005-1238                                                                               Page 6                    
                Application No. 09/874,031                                                                                                   



                        With this as background, we analyze the prior art applied by the examiner in the                                     
                rejection of the claims on appeal.                                                                                           


                        Turner's invention is related to the protection of potted growing plants during                                      
                shipping.  As shown in Figure 1, a plant 5 is planted or grown in a pot 16 in potting soil 6                                 
                covered with a relatively thin layer of fibrous bedding material 7, usually about one-half                                   
                to one and one-half inches thick, to hold the potting soil in place during shipping of the                                   
                potted plant.  An open-mesh cover 10 is placed over and against the layer of bedding                                         
                material and secured to the pot to hold the bedding material, and thus the potting soil, in                                  
                place.                                                                                                                       


                        In one of Turner's embodiments, the open-mesh cover comprises a set of                                               
                one-sixteenth inch diameter plastic rods spaced one inch apart and-fastened to a                                             
                second set of such rods having their longitudinal axis at an angle of about 90 degrees                                       
                from the longitudinal axis of the first set of rods.  In this embodiment, the pot is provided                                
                with a lip extending around the inside surface of the pot near its top.  The open-mesh                                       
                cover is trimmed to fit inside the pot and snapped into place beneath the lip.                                               


                        Turner's preferred embodiment of open-mesh cover is shown in Figures 2 and 3.                                        
                This cover comprises a ring 10 of O-shaped cross-section as shown in Figure 3 having                                         







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007