Ex Parte Olivera et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2005-1481                                                        
          Application 10/236,601                                                      

                    Display monitor unit 10 can be mounted on a                       
               reference surface 18.  The reference surface, as shown                 
               in FIG. 1, is a horizontal top surface, such as a                      
               table.  Alternatively, the reference surface may be a                  
               vertical surface such as a wall (as shown in FIG. 3),                  
               or an overhead surface such as a ceiling (as shown in                  
               FIG. 4).  Moreover, the reference surface may be at any                
               angle or inclination, such that the display monitor                    
               unit may be mounted in a horizontal, vertical, angled                  
               or upside down orientation.  The term, reference                       
               surface, herein, shall be used generally to refer to                   
               any mounting surface of the display monitor unit of any                
               orientation [column 3, lines 11 through 30].                           

               Rosen also briefly discusses the audio, video and power                
          inputs to the display monitor unit:                                         

                    [a]udio, video and power inputs may be contained                  
               within the display monitor unit.  Alternatively, the                   
               audio, video and power inputs may also extend directly                 
               to the screen.  In the depicted embodiment, the                        
               mounting plate has an opening for the audio and power                  
               inputs which run through base 12 and into the end of                   
               proximal region 46 of arm 14 and up through distal                     
               region 48 of arm 14 and into rear screen housing 60 of                 
               screen 16.  Moreover, base 12 may have a built in                      
               antenna or battery power source.  Base 12 may also                     
               include a recessed plug for a tuner or other device                    
               [column 6, lines 56 through 65].                                       

               As conceded by the examiner (see page 3 in the answer),                
          Rosen lacks response to the limitation in independent claim 1               
          requiring a helical cable wrap contained in the spindle assembly,           
          and to the corresponding limitations in independent claim 8                 


                                          4                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007