Ex Parte Sudolcan - Page 5




               Appeal No. 2005-2615                                                                       5                                      
               Application No. 09/908,405                                                                                                        


               communication with the heads and bottles.  The encoder does not participate in the                                                
               communication between the computer and the heads 12 much less prevent serial                                                      
               communication between the heads and the computer in one position.  Further, as                                                    
               Peckels discloses that the computer can communicate with several heads                                                            
               simultaneously, it is clear that Peckels does not describe a system in which                                                      
               communication between the heads and the computer 24 is prevented when the                                                         
               computer 24 is in communication with a specific head (col. 17, lines 26 to 33).                                                   
                      As Peckels does not describe a serial data jumper movable to a first position                                              
               that inhibits flow of serial communication data beyond the volumetric module thereby                                              
               allowing the system controller to assign an address to the volumetric module as                                                   
               required by claim 1, we will not sustain the examiner's rejection of claim 1 and claims 6                                         
               through 9 dependent thereon.  Claim 10 contains the identical language regarding a                                                
               serial data jumper as in claim 1 and therefore we will not sustain the rejection as it is                                         
               directed to claim 10 and claims 11 through 17).                                                                                   




























Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007