Ex Parte Mallebrein - Page 3




              Appeal No. 2006-0109                                                                Παγε 3                                       
              Application No. 10/350,187                                                                                                       


              respective positions articulated by the appellant and the examiner.  As a consequence                                            
              of our review, we make the determinations which follow.                                                                          
                     Each of appellant’s claims on appeal recites a method, or a program for carrying                                          
              out a method, comprising steps of adjusting a first continuously shiftable parameter so                                          
              that at least one condition variable of the combustion of a combustion chamber                                                   
              assigned to said inlet valve does not change when later switching over a second                                                  
              parameter which can be switched in steps and then switching over said second                                                     
              parameter.  In rejecting claims 1-3, 6 and 9-12 as being anticipated by Kabasin, the                                             
              examiner reads the phasing of the intake cam relative to the engine crankshaft as the                                            
              first, continuously shiftable, parameter and the position of the two-step switching device                                       
              as the second parameter.  With the two-step switching device in the first position, an                                           
              associated engine valve is actuated, i.e., lifted, according to a high-lift cam.  With the                                       
              two-step switching device in the second position, the associated engine valve is                                                 
              actuated/lifted according to a low-lift cam of the camshaft.                                                                     
                     It is apparent from the disclosure of Kabasin in columns 9 through 12 that the                                            
              phasing will be switched before the two-step switching device in at least two situations.                                        
              First, in the case where the load check 204 and high-lift position check 206 determine                                           
              that the two-step switching device needs to be switched to the high-lift position, if the                                        
              high-load hysteresis check 212 determines that the desired load is less than the                                                 
              predetermined high-load hysteresis threshold1, the electronic throttle control module                                            
                                                                                                                                              
                     1 The predetermined high-load hysteresis threshold is slightly greater than the predetermined load                        















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007