Ex Parte Serbutoviez et al - Page 6




                     thick -- vacuum enclosure was carried out at the 12-micrometer cell (20x20mm of                    
                     viewing areas) Then, using the black light, by irradiating for 120 seconds by the                  
                     irradiation intensity of l5 mW/cm2, a monomer and oligomer were hardened                           
                     (radical polymerization), 2 phase separation of macromolecule matrices was                         
                     considered as liquid crystal, and the PDLC element was created. The given energy                   
                     is equivalent to 1800 mJ/cm2. The obtained element showed the good dispersion                      
                     state in the state where voltage is not impressed.  (brackets in original).                        
                     (0021)                                                                                             
                     (Effect of the Invention) As explained above, the luminosity of projected type                     
                     display of this invention is improving sharply by use of unnecessary PDLC of a                     
                     polarizing plate. When it applies to projected type display while driver voltage fell              
                     sharply, consequently the drive of PDLC furthermore used for this invention with                   
                     TFT or an MIM element was attained, it is bright and the clear high image display                  
                     of a contrast ratio is possible for it.                                                            

                                                        Opinion                                                         
                     During examination, the Office bears the initial burden of establishing a prima facie case         
              of obviousness.  In re Bell,  991 F.2d 781, 783,  26 USPQ2d 1529, 1530 (Fed. Cir. 1993).  Thus,           
              the Office must establish that the one of ordinary skill in the art would have selected the               
              appropriate materials from the prior art and combine them in the manner claimed by Serbutoviez.           
                     Serbutoviez’s claim 5 is directed to a polymerizable mixture whereas claim 9 is directed           
              to a display device having a cell manufactured from a polymerizable mixture.  The polymerizable           
              mixtures recited in Serbutoviez’s claims 5 and 9 are said to contain:                                     
                     two types of non-volatile reactive monomers, the first type of monomer being an                    
                     ethoxylated acrylate and readily miscible with a liquid crystalline material and the               
                     second type of monomer being poorly miscible with said liquid crystalline                          
                     material.                                                                                          
              (Brief, Claims Appendix, Claims 5 and 9).                                                                 





                                                           6                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007