Ex Parte Harif - Page 8



         Appeal No. 2006-0796                                     Page 8          
         Application No. 09/607,751                                               
              From the disclosure of Semret, we find that the reference           
         does teach the network server to be configured to provide a bid          
         solicitation from a network host for a process execution                 
         requested by a network client.  In Semret, when a seller player          
         agent 102 decides to accept bids for a specified amount of               
         bandwidth, resource agent 104 solicits bids from different buyer         
         player agents. To the extent that the different buyers can be            
         considered network hosts, this limitation of claim 1 is met.             
         However, because resource agent 104 receives the bids and                
         determines the winning buyer or buyers, Semret does not teach a          
         network server that simulates a process execution.  Similarly,           
         Semret does not teach simulating the process execution by                
         estimating computing resources required to carry out the                 
         execution process.                                                       
              We are not persuaded by the examiner’s assertion (answer,           
         pages 7 and 8) that Semret’s pricing simulations (pages 57-62) of        
         the article that is attached to the patent application is a              
         teaching of simulating the process execution.  The fact that the         
         article discloses pricing simulations using Monte-Carlo                  
         simulation, is not a disclosure of simulating a process execution        









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007