Ex Parte No Data - Page 10



         Appeal No. 2006-0790                                                       
         Reexamination Control No. 90/005,117                                       

                   associating the tread base with the upright structure            
                   is found at column 15, lines 3-28.                               
              18. The inventors disclose that gas spring 505 of the ‘624            
                   patent is part of a lift assist assembly.  (Column 15,           
      5            lines 3-28.)                                                     
              19. The inventors disclose the function or purpose of the             
                   gas spring as follows: “The force and the torque (TF)            
                   exerted by the spring 505 is selected so that the                
                   resulting required lifting force (LF) may be nominal             
     10            (e.g. 5 to 20 pounds).”  (Column 15, lines 22-24.)               
              20. Teague teaches that the gas springs, like the gas                 
                   spring described in the ‘624 patent, provide a lifting           
                   force.  (Column 2, lines 3-8.)                                   
              21. Appealed claim 1 does not limit the degree or manner              
     15            in which the gas spring “assist[s] in stably                     
                   retaining” the tread base at the storage position.               
              22. The appellant has not proffered any evidence (e.g.,               
                   declaration evidence) that would support the                     
                   allegation that Teague’s gas spring does not “assist”            
     20            in stable retention.                                             



                                         10                                         



Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007