Ex Parte Barbir et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2006-0892                                       Page 4           
          Application No. 10/202,701                                                  

               While Yang furnishes an example of a bipolar plate                     
          configuration having an eight inch width and length, Yang clearly           
          is not limited to that exemplified embodiment.  Indeed, Yang                
          makes it clear that such an equal length and width bipolar plate            
          configuration is merely illustrative by expressly noting that               
          other configurations of the plate are within the purview of the             
          disclosed invention.  See column 6, lines 3-5 of Yang.                      
          In this regard, the claimed rectangular geometry for a                      
          bipolar plate flow region would have been well within the ambit             
          of one of ordinary skill in the art from the disclosure of Yang             
          given that disclosure concerning the inclusion of a variety of              
          geometries or configurations for the plate structures thereof.              
          Concerning this matter, Yang provides that the bipolar plate                
          configuration should allow for the requisite uniform pressure               
          drop and desired clearing of reactants and humidity from the                
          channels in the flow regions of the bipolar plates by using flow            
          restrictions in those channels as taught by Yang (column 3, lines           
          3-43).  After all, the configuration or shape of the plates and             
          associated flow regions of Yang in a rectangular geometry would             
          be attended by a reasonable expectation of success in that                  
          bipolar plates and flow regions of such shapes would be expected            
          to operate with the desired reactant and humidity clearing                  





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007