Ex Parte Hansmann et al - Page 2



         Appeal No. 2006-0986                                                                        
         Application No. 09/745,818                                                                  

              a device for reading and initiating update of the payment                              
         status comprising at least:                                                                 
              a contactless reader for reading information stored in said                            
         contactless label chipcard                                                                  
              a component for generating an invoice based on said                                    
         information received from said contactless label chipcard                                   
              a component for checking payment of said invoice                                       
              a component for initiating update of the payment status in the                         
         contactless label chipcard.                                                                 
                                   THE REFERENCES                                                    
         Boers et al. (Boers)              5,637,846        Jun. 10, 1997                            
         Brookner et al. (Brookner)       WO 99/66456       Dec. 23, 1999                            
              (PCT application)                                                                      
                                   THE REJECTION                                                     
              Claims 1-24 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being                              
         unpatentable over Boers in view of Brookner.                                                
                                      OPINION                                                        
              We reverse the aforementioned rejection.  We need to address                           
         only the independent claims, i.e., claims 1, 13-15 and 22-24.                               
         Claim 1 requires a contactless label chipcard which is attached to                          
         a product and contains 1) information identifying the payment                               
         status of the product, and 2) a component for executing an update                           
         of the payment status of the product.  Claim 1 also requires a                              
         device for reading and initiating update of the payment status.                             
                                         2                                                           











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007