Ex Parte Levy et al - Page 4


                Appeal No. 2006-1083                                                                                 Page 4                    
                Application No. 09/799,251                                                                                                     

                deficiency anemia, folic acid to prevent neural tube defects, [and] compounds to reduce                                        
                serum homocysteine and improve the lipid profile” (id., lines 57-62).  In addition,                                            
                phytoestrogens, “a class of isoflavones or isoflavenoids derived from plants, commonly                                         
                soy beans” (id., column 4, lines 65-67), “are included in each of the dietary supplements”                                     
                (id., lines 51-54).  In addition, the dietary supplements may optionally contain provitamin                                    
                A carotenoids, like cryptoxanthin, and/or non-provitamin carotenoids, such as lutein and                                       
                lycopene (id., column 6, line 63 to column 7, line 5).  According to Jackson,                                                  
                phytoestrogens “modulate the menstrual cycle, reduce menopausal symptoms, and                                                  
                lower LDL cholesterol levels” (id., column 4, lines 53-55), moreover, “diets rich in                                           
                phytoestrogen[s] . . . [result in] a decreased incidence of breast cancer, menopausal                                          
                symptoms and osteoporosis” (id., lines 57-59), while lycopene “has been inversely                                              
                associated with the risk of cervical cancer” (id., column 7, lines 7-8).                                                       
                         Shlyankevich describes dietary supplements “effective in the prevention of the                                        
                onset of clinical manifestations of osteoporosis” (Shlyankevich, column 3, lines 12-13).                                       
                The supplements comprise at least eight “active ingredients” (id., lines 15-16), including                                     
                phytoestrogens, licorice root extract, calcium, magnesium, zinc, beta-carotene,                                                
                cholecalciferol, and vitamin E (id., lines 18-31).  Shlyankevich teaches that                                                  
                phytoestrogens “have the ability to improve hormonal balance, [ ] are highly effective in                                      
                the treatment of osteoporosis” (id., column 5, line 68 to column 6, line 1), and are                                           
                “associated with the reduction of free plasma estradiol, and the risk of breast cancer” (id.,                                  
                column 2, lines 58-61).  Thus, “[n]atural dietary phytoestrogens can replace estrogen                                          
                therapy” (id., column 5, lines 65-66), without the “side effects and other risk factors                                        
                associated with using estrogens . . . to prevent postmenopausal osteoporosis” (id.,                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007