Ex Parte Ferree - Page 5



         Appeal No. 2006-1877                                                       
         Application 10/434,931                                                     

         since appellant has not provided any response on the record to the examiner’s position.1
         Accordingly, the rejection of claim 6 is sustained.                        
         Regarding the rejection of claims 7 and 8 based on Harrington,             
         the examiner indicates on page 5 of the answer that the ADR of             
         Harrington includes a plurality of spring members (68, 69) which           
         each form a joint having a center of rotation, and that those              
         respective centers of rotation cooperate to form an overall center         
         of rotation for the ADR. We agree, noting again that appellant has         
         not provided any response on the record to the examiner’s position,        
         and has definitely not explained why the springs (68, 69) in the ADR       
         of Harrington do not each broadly provide a joint having a center of       
         rotation, and why those respective centers of rotation would not           
         cooperate to form an overall center of rotation for the ADR. We            
         again direct attention to page 4 of the answer for the examiner’s          
         position on the “center of rotation” issue. Thus, the rejection of         
         claims 7 and 8 is also sustained.                                          



                                                                                   
              1During any further prosecution of this application, the              
         examiner should consider whether a rejection of claim 6 under 35           
         U.S.C. § 112, first and/or second paragraphs, would be                     
         appropriate.                                                               



                                          5                                         


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007