Ex Parte Aleles et al - Page 43



             Appeal No. 2006-2248                                                                               
             Application No. 10/158,618                                                                         

             defects, but we hold so for different reasons than set forth by Appellants.                        
             According to the Examiner, the reissue declaration:                                                
                   [D]oes not contain a statement that all errors which are being                               
                   corrected in the reissue application up to the time of filing of the                         
                   oath/declaration arose without any deceptive intention on the part of                        
                   the applicant.                                                                               
             We find such a statement at page 3 of Exhibit B, rather than at page 2 of Exhibit A                
             as pointed out by Appellants.   We find this statement sufficient.  According to the               
             Examiner:                                                                                          
                   [T]here is no reference [in the reissue declaration] to the Declaration                      
                   filed by Andrea L. Colby in the Reissue declaration or incorporate by                        
                   reference of the [Colby Declaration].                                                        
             We find no requirement in the statute or rules that the reissue declaration refer to or            
             incorporate by reference other declarations that Appellants may have filed.                        
             Applicants are free to file other declarations that are separate from the reissue                  
             declaration.  Thus, we find no error.  However, because the Colby declaration is a                 
             separate declaration, it does not serve to fulfill the requirements of the reissue                 
             declaration.                                                                                       





                                                     - 43 -                                                     




Page:  Previous  36  37  38  39  40  41  42  43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007