Ex Parte Fulmer et al - Page 11


            Appeal No. 2006-2485                                                        Page 11              
            Application No. 10/925,646                                                                       

            3.  Veldman                                                                                      
                   The examiner has rejected claims 1, 7-10, 22, and 23 under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b)             
            as anticipated by Veldman.2  The examiner states that Veldman “teach[es] a method of             
            reducing iron in hydrocarbon streams by contacting with a mixture of oxygen                      
            scavengers comprising a mixture of quinone and hydroxylamine.  In reference to a                 
            closed loop system, Veldman teaches cleaning piping of stainless steel equipment.”               
            Examiner’s Answer, page 4.  The examiner also notes that “Example 1 [of Veldman]                 
            (col. 6-7 bridging) teaches treating a plant [with] the claimed composition and                  
            decreasing the amount of iron and corrosion as a result of treatment.  Col. 7, lines 1-10,       
            teaches that the plant, prior to treatment, has an increasing amount of total iron               
            concentration.  After treatment with the claimed composition, corrosion was reduced              
            and the iron content decreased.”  Examiner’s Answer, page 8. The examiner reasons                
            that “the [claim] limitations are inherently met since Veldman is performing the same            
            steps using the same composition, as the instantly claimed invention.”  Id.                      
                   We conclude that the examiner has presented a prima facie case that Veldman               
            anticipates claim 1.  Veldman describes “a method of inhibiting corrosion in gas or light        
            hydrocarbon treating systems . . . by adding to the treating solution a mixture of oxygen        
            scavengers from 0.001 to 50,000 ppm comprised of mixtures of a quinone and                       
            hydroxylamines” of a particular formula.  Col. 2, line 65, to col. 3, line 4.  The preferred     
            hydroxylamines include diethylhydroxylamine.  Col. 3, lines 13-18.  “The oxygen                  
            scavengers can advantageously be mixed in deionized water.  The resulting aqueous                
            solution is preferably added to [the] treating solution in a concentration of 0.0001-50,000      
                                                                                                             
            2 Veldman et al., U.S. Patent No. 6,059,992, issued May 9, 2000.                                 





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007