Ex Parte Spear et al - Page 9

                 Appeal 2006-2619                                                                                   
                 Application 10/935,566                                                                             

                 is the remote operation of a welding device (Niedereder, col. 1, ll. 51-63).                       
                 Thus, we find that one of ordinary skill in this art would have considered the                     
                 disclosure of the reference in the context of a welding device which                               
                 includes, among other components, “a welding current” source, that is, a                           
                 welding power supply.  In this respect, Niedereder would have disclosed to                         
                 this person that the “[t]he invention related to a welding device having a                         
                 current source” and other components including “a control and evaluation                           
                 unit” and “a communication interface,” wherein the “system is that data can                        
                 be forwarded to the welding device from a remote site” (Niedereder, e.g.,                          
                 col. 1, l. 66, to col. 2, l. 61).                                                                  
                       Indeed, the system can be used in “a method of operating a welding                           
                 device wherein this method includes the steps of controlling an energy                             
                 source via a control or evaluation unit to apply electrical energy to at least                     
                 one electrode,” wherein the “control and evaluation unit can process                               
                 software modules and operates on the basis of a pre-set set of instructions                        
                 and any specific settings entered” to configure the energy source                                  
                 (Niedereder, col. 4, l. 66, to col. 5, l. 19).  We find that Niedereder further                    
                 would have disclosed with respect to Fig. 1, a “welding device 1                                   
                 [comprising] a current source 2 with a power component 3, a control and/or                         
                 evaluation unit 4,” and that “the current needed to generate an arc 15                             
                 between the welding wire 13 and a workpiece 16 is fed via supply line 17,                          
                 18 from the power component 3 of the current source 2 to the welding torch                         
                 10 and the welding wire 13” (Niedereder, col. 6, ll. 29-49; see also col. 9, ll.                   
                 49-64).  In this respect, input and/or output device 22 can be used to set a                       
                 range of welding parameters and operating modes which are forwarded to                             


                                                         9                                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007