Ex Parte Blackwell et al - Page 2

                Appeal 2006-2874                                                                                   
                Application 09/888,044                                                                             


                       a first rear vertical support and a second rear vertical support attached                   
                to said face panel, said rear vertical supports being spaced apart and                             
                extending along the length of said face panel, said first rear vertical support                    
                being positioned adjacent to said first vertical end portion and said second                       
                rear vertical support being positioned adjacent to said second vertical end                        
                portion; and                                                                                       
                       at least one rear horizontal support attached to said face panel, said                      
                rear horizontal support extending in between said pair of rear vertical                            
                supports; and                                                                                      
                       a first channel member and a second channel member, each of said                            
                channel members having a U-shaped cross-section and being made from a                              
                metal, said first channel member being placed over and enclosing said first                        
                vertical end portion and said first rear vertical support and said second                          
                channel member being placed over and enclosing said second vertical end                            
                portion and said second rear vertical support, the first and second channel                        
                members forming exterior vertical edges of the shutter.                                            
                                          GROUND OF REJECTION                                                      
                       Claims 1-20 stand rejected under 35 USC § 103 as unpatentable over                          
                Taylor in view of Ruggles.                                                                         
                       The Examiner relies upon the following references as evidence of                            
                obviousness:                                                                                       
                Taylor    US 5,848,505   Dec. 15, 1998                                                             
                Ruggles    US 6,014,839   Jan. 18, 2000                                                            
                                                BACKGROUND                                                         
                       The invention is directed to a shutter made from a synthetic polymer                        
                that is said to have improved strength.  The shutter includes a face panel                         
                attached to a first rear vertical support and a second rear vertical support.                      
                First and second channel members secure the face panel to the rear vertical                        
                supports and enclose the corresponding vertical end portions and rear                              


                                                        2                                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007