Ex Parte Fukumoto - Page 12



           Appeal No. 2006-2936                                                                      
           Application No. 10/013,714                                                                
           setting property level access to specify which users can access                           
           which piece of information in the database. Britton also teaches an                       
           access control list (ACL) indicating which levels in the database                         
           each user is allowed to access.  The ACL restricts access to a                            
           particular level in the database only to users that have acquired                         
           the necessary security level permission to access such level of                           
           data.                                                                                     
                 It is our view that one of ordinary skill in the art at the                         
           time of the present invention would have readily found that                               
           Britton’s teachings amount to the Appellant’s invention as set                            
           forth in representative claim 1.  The ordinarily skilled artisan                          
           would have duly recognized that every time a user or a program                            
           submits a request to access a level of data in the database, such                         
           request is routed to the database via an interface program, which                         
           subsequently accesses the database.  From the point of view of                            
           the database, whether the request is submitted by an actual user                          
           or a program, such request can only access the database via the                           
           interface program.  Hence, from the database standpoint, the                              
           interface program, which serves as a proxy for the user or the                            
           program can only access a particular level of the database if the                         
           identification data provided by the interface program has already                         
           been granted the necessary permission to access such level,                               

                                                 12                                                  




Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007