Ex Parte Carnali et al - Page 2



            1          B.  Record considered                                                                      
            2          The record considered in the appeal consists solely of:                                    
            3                 1.  The specification, drawings and claims as originally filed.                     
            4                 2.  European Patent Application 0 851 022 A2.                                       
            5                 3.  The final rejection entered 11 December 2003                                    
            6                 4.  Brief for Appellants filed 15 March 2004.                                       
            7                 5.  Order returning undocketed appeal to Examiner entered                           
            8   18 July 2005.                                                                                     
            9                 5.  Supplemental Examiner's Answer mailed on 27 or 28 July                          
          10    2005.                                                                                             
          11                  6.  Examiner's communication mailed 9 August 2005.                                  
          12                  7.  Appeal docketing notice of appeal received on 15 August                         
          13    2006.                                                                                             
          14           C.  The invention                                                                          
          15           The invention sought to be patented can be understood by reference to                      
          16    claims 1 and 12.                                                                                  
          17                                        Claim 1                                                       
          18           A mechanical dishwashing composition comprising:                                           
          19                  (A) an anti-scaling polymer formed from                                             
          20                        (i) 50 to 99% by weight of the polymer of an                                  
          21    olefinically unsaturated carboxylic acid monomer;                                                 
          22                        (ii) 1 to 50% of at least one monomer unit selected                           
          23    from the group consisting of copolymerizable sulfonated monomers,                                 
          24    copolymerizable nonionic monomers and mixtures thereof;                                           
          25                  (B) 0.1 to 99.9% of a vehicle designed to release at least an                       
          26    effective amount of the polymer to prevent scaling;                                               


                                                        2                                                         


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007