Steven M. and Michele E. Grow - Page 5

                                                    5                                                      
            that the investment of the distribution in a house with a 30-year                              
            mortgage is akin to a retirement account, and therefore, tax free                              
            treatment of the distribution comports with the Congressional                                  
            intent underlying the tax treatment of retirement plans.  Cf.                                  
            Harris v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1994-22 (which is contrary to                               
            petitioner's argument).  Petitioner further argues that the                                    
            distribution was made out of necessity, due to petitioners'                                    
            inability to sell their house, and as such, literal application                                
            of the Internal Revenue Code is inappropriate.                                                 
                  While we sympathize with petitioners, we are not at liberty                              
            to create exceptions to the Internal Revenue Code.  It is a well-                              
            established principle that "exemptions from taxation are not to                                
            be implied; they must be unambiguously proved."  United States v.                              
            Wells Fargo Bank, 485 U.S. 351, 354 (1988).                                                    
                  To reflect the foregoing,                                                                
                                                        Decision will be entered                           
                                                  for respondent.                                          

















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  

Last modified: May 25, 2011